
ns Vol. IV.
Cherry Valley, N.Y., Thursday, February 11, 1858.
No. 7.

MORMONISM.
We make the following extracts from the speech of Mr. John Thompson of this state, delivered in the House of
Representatives, Jan. 27.:
"Mormonism, as a religious system, had its origin in a romance, written about the year 1810 by
Solomon Spalding, a native of Connecticut, who had been educated for the ministry, but followed a mercantile employment,
removed to Cherry Valley, N. Y., where he amused his leisure hours by weaving a book entitled by him, "The MSS.
Found," the notion entertained or suggested by some writers that the American Indians are the descendants of the lost
ten tribes of Israel. -- Hence, he starts them from Palestine, invents for them various fortunes by flood and field,
wars, quarrels, turmoils, strifes, separations, until they people this continent, and leave behind them the vestiges
of mounds, tumuli, fortifications, sculpture, and cities dilapidated, which are discovered in Northern and Central
America. It is written somewhat in Scriptural style, and uses the machinery of the Jewish economy throughout. He read
his manuscript to various persons, who yet remember it, but was not successful in procuring its publication. Somewhere,
about the year 1823, this manuscript fell into the hands of Jo Smith, a native of Windsor County, Vt. Smith was about
twenty years of age, and already exhibited that singular compound of genius and folly, of cunning and absurdity, of
indolence and energy, of craft and earnestness, which distinguished him to the end of his career.
"Under the new-light preachers of that day, Smith became imbued with all the wild and extravagant notions of seeing
sights, hearing voices, receiving revelations, meeting and fighting the devil in bodily form, which indicate a diseased
imagination and want of all solid instruction and fixed principles on religious subjects. Enthusiasm ran mad through
the whole region where he dwelt, and Smith was one of its most brilliant exemplifications, ultimately having a
revelation that all existing systems of religion were wrong, and that he should be made the prophet of a new faith.
For more than five years he vibrated between his caution and his enthusiasm, giving out occasionally dark hints about
certain mysterious plates to be dug up by him, containing a new revelation. Part of his time was spent in lying,
swindling and debauchery, and the remainder in visions and repentance -- the vulgar habits of the brute contending with
the higher functions of the prophet. At length he pretended to dig out the plates from the side of a hill in Palmyra,
Wayne County, N. Y., placed himself behind a curtain, permitting no one to enter, from which sanctum he translated
from the plates the book of Mormon to an amanuensis, reading it all from Spalding's manuscript in his possession, one
hundred and eighteen pages of it having been stolen by Martin Harris. -- With this new Koran our modern Mohammed
started upon his career.
"On the 5th of May, 1829, John the Baptist came back to earth to baptize Smith; and on the 6th of April, 1830, the
first church of Latter-Day Saints was organized at Manchester, New York, consisting of four Smith and two converts out
of the family -- Pratt, Rigdon, Kimball, and Young joining afterward. The Bible, unlike that of the Christian or
Mussulman, purports to be chiefly historical, and does not enunciate or enforce a system of moral and religious truth
in a philosophic or didactic form; all its incidental lessons upon life or manners being derived from current doctrines
of this day. It is consequently incapable of comparison with any other extant form of religious faith. One might as
well compare the Christian religion with Fenelon's Telemachus, or one of Jame's novels.
"The history of this fanaticism is soon told. The church was organized in 1830. In August, 1831, they commenced a
settlement at Independence, Jackson County, Missouri -- revealed to Smith as the site of the "New Jerusalem." Smith
wavered long between this place and Kirtland, Ohio, where in '33, they commenced building their first temple, which was
finished in 1836, at a cost of about $50,000. In '39 they relaid the foundations of their temple in Missouri. They left
this region again for Nauvoo, in Illinois, where another temple was soon erected. Jo Smith's life and labors ended
together in Carthage Jail, where, on the 27th of June, 1844, he was shot by a gang of Border Ruffians from Missouri.
"In '45 they turned their eyes westward -- to Vancouver's Island, to Texas, to California, and finally to a valley in
the Rocky Mountains. In 1843 [sic - 1846?], as the young grass was peering from the sod and the buds were bursting into
flowers, in the month of May, the exodus to Utah commenced.
"From that day Young has reigned supreme, and thousands and tens of thousands have flocked to his standard. The
unsettled religious sentiment of the lower grades of mind gravitate to Salt Lake. It is the Botany Bay of the world!
There it stands, rampant and defying -- a despotism consummate, wearing the show of popular approval, and bending
willingly to the nod of a tyrant. -- There it stands -- it is before you in your path to the Pacific -- it will not
[sway] at your bidding; a huge, ugly, stubborn fact, which no ignorance can disregard and no political fatuity despise.
"What will you do with it? Will you turn despot and saber 60,000 souls because they believe in Brigham Young and
polygamy? -- Will you meet the fanaticism and folly and fraud by the fanaticism of extermination? -- Will you make the
city a desert and the region a howling wilderness on the one hand; or, will you suffer this moral cancer, inflaming
political treason, to grow on untouched until it becomes to vast to handle? Will you permit an independent and defiant
despotism, organized in the very heart of this continent and embracing the vilest and most intractable elements of
which a community can be composed, to compact and strengthen its defenses, to train its battalions, to call home its
forces, and light a fire at your threshold which all the forces of the Republic cannot subdue?
"I know some think we should let them alone, and that the system must soon fall to pieces. But how long has
Mohammedanism lasted? How much reliable is the fanaticism of to-day than that of ten centuries ago? What element of
this structure gives signs of impotence or decay? What limb of this hale giant is already smitten with moral paralysis,
and gives tokens that its energies are spent or even wearied? Sir, we have let them alone, and from a contemptible
handful, they have grown into a nation! The citizens of Illinois and Missouri could eject them without aid; but now
they stand behind a wall of ten thousand bayonets, and dare you to the encounter. The unorganized fanaticism of the
world gravitates to Utah, and there it is molded into armies. Eight tenths at least of these elements are foreign,
uneducated by and unaccustomed to our institutions, with no love for Democracy, and no reverence for national law;
restless masses, impatient of restraint, and fraternizing only on the lust of license and the hope of power."
==> Mr. Bernheisel, delegate from Utah, has had several conferences with the President recently. He proposes
that the troops be withdrawn and a Commission dispatched to the territory to arrange for the settlement of present
difficulties. Mr. Bernheisel speaks in the name of the people of Utah, not pursuance to instructions from Brigham
Young. The President turns a cold shoulder to his proposition.
Note 1: See the New York Hornellsville Tribune of
Feb. 11, 1858 for a similar report on
Representative Thompson's speech. The article is one of the very few known to have been printed in the Otsego County
press, in which Solomon Spalding's ostensible connections to the Book of Mormon were outlined. Since this text was
reprinted in a Cherry Valley paper, and since it makes mention of Spalding's early residence in Cherry Valley, it is
surprising that the Gazette editor appended no local comments, nor subsequently published any follow-up items
concerning Solomon Spalding at Cherry Valley. Certainly, as late as 1858, there must have yet been living a few old
Otsego Co. pioneers who recalled Spalding's c. 1795-1809 stay in the area (at which time he served briefly as the
Headmaster of the noted Cherry Valley Academy). Representative Thompson presents the intriguing nation -- that Spalding
began his fictional writings on the subject of lost Israelite tribes, while living in Cherry Valley. However, the
most that can be said about the local response to this assertion, is that there was no known refutation forthcoming
from Otsego's old settlers.
Note 2: An earlier news report (probably first published in Otsego County, about the beginning of October, 1850) gave
some interesting information that was soon after reprinted in the Boston New England Puritan: [At a
public meeting lately held in Cherry Valley, Judge Campbell said:] ... "Rev. Solomon Spaulding, one of the earliest
preceptors of the Academy of Cherry Valley, was the actual composer of most of what is known as the Mormon Bible. He
wrote it during a period of delicate health to beguile some of his weary hours, and also with a design to offer it
for publication as a romance. Dr. Robert Campbell, late of Cherry Valley, and foster father of the first Mrs. Grant,
of the Nestorian mission, calling some years since upon Mr. Spaulding, had the manuscript of this notable book to be
shown to him, and was also informed by Mr. Spaulding that he had hopes of reaping some pecuniary advantage from it for
himself and family. Mr. Spaulding has been dead for some years, though it is believed that his wife is still living
in the United States. How it passed from the possession of his family into the hands of Joe Smith it is probable that
Mrs. Spaulding could tell."
|