
Vol. 1. No. 9.
Davis City, Iowa, September, 1889.
Whole No. 9.
[131]
ITEMS OF PERSONAL HISTORY
OF THE EDITOR.
_____
No. 5. [sic - 6]
_____
INCLUDING SOME ITEMS OF CHURCH
HISTORY NOT GENERALLY KNOWN.
_____
(Continued from Page 121.)
In our last article we gave the proceedings of the High Council in Kirtland, O. that were had on the 29th of May, 1837,
and also of the High Council of the church in Far West, Missouri, on the 10th of March, 1838; at both of those places
David Whitmer and Oliver Cowdery took part. They moved from Ohio to Missouri in the summer or fall of 1837.
On the 7th of Nov. 1837, at a general assembly of the church at Far West, David Whitmer was chosen President of the
church in Missouri (a place he had formerly filled, before he went to Kirtland to be present at the dedication of the
temple,) and John Whitmer and W. W. Phelps were chosen to be his counsellors; these three to constitute the three
Presidents of the church in Zion, as it was called, and Oliver Cowdery was chosen clerk.
Notwithstanding, these men were appointed to these positions yet the disaffection continued, until "at a meeting of
the High Council, the bishop and his council, February 10th, 1838, it was moved, seconded and carried, that Oliver
Cowdery, W. W. Phelps and John Whitmer stand no longer as chairman and clerk to sign licenses." And on the
10th of March, further action was had in the cases of Presidents Phelps and John Whitmer, as given on the 120th page
of the August No. of THE RETURN.
On the 14th of March, 1838, Joseph Smith, jr., arrived at Far West, with his family, and on the 4th of April Sidney
Rigdon also arrived with his family.
Joseph Smith, jr., was held in very high esteem by the masses of the people, members of the church, and looked upon as
being invested with powers and qualifications far above all other men, being, as they thought, a great Prophet of God,
like unto Moses, and that like Elisha, he
[132]
could tell their actions, and almost their thoughts, when absent from them. They rejoiced to think they were permitted
to live to see the day when prophets and apostles were restored to the earth again, therefore there was great rejoicing
when he arrived among them, as will be seen by the following extract from a letter written by him after his arrival,
copied from page 130, 16th vol. Millennial Star.
"Far West, March 29th, 1838.
To the Presidency of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints in Kirtland.
Dear and well-beloved Brethren -- Through the grace and mercy of our God, after a long and tedious journey of two months
and one day, I and my family arrived safe in the city of Far West, having been met at Huntsville, one hundred and twenty
miles from the place, by my brethren with teams and money, to forward us on our journey. When within eight miles of the
city of Far West, we were met by an escort of brethren from the city, viz: Thomas B. Marsh, John Corrill, Elias Higbee,
and several others of the faithful of the west, who received us with open arms and warm hearts, and welcomed us to the
bosom of their society. On our arrival in the city we were greeted on every hand by the Saints, who bid us welcome to
the land of their inheritance."
We now quote from the history of Joseph Smith, Jr., as found on page 131 of the 16th volume Millennial Star.
"Far West, April 6th, 1838.
Agreeable to a resolution passed by the High Council of Zion, March 3rd, 1838, the saints in Missouri assembled in this
place, to celebrate the anniversary of the church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and to transact church business,
Joseph Smith, Junior, and Sidney Rigdon presiding.
The meeting was opened by singing, and prayer by David W. Patten, after which President Smith, junior, read the order
of the day. * * *
The meeting then proceeded to business. George Morey was appointed Sexton, and Dimick Huntington, assistant; John Corrill
and Elias Higbee, Historians; George W. Robinson, General Church Recorder, and Clerk to the First Presidency; Ebenezer
Robinson, Church Clerk and Recorder for Far West, and Clerk of the High Council; Thomas B. Marsh, President pro tempore
of the Church in Zion, and David W. Patten and Brigham Young, his assistant Presidents.
After one hour's adjournment, meeting again opened by David W. Patten. The bread and wine were administered, and
ninety-five infants were blessed.
Joseph Smith, junior, President.
E. Robinson, Clerk."
We have preserved, and have before us at the present writing, the original minutes of the above meeting as taken down
at the time.
It will be seen, that at this meeting Thomas B. Marsh, David W. Patten and Brigham Young were appointed presidents over
the church in Missouri, although David Whitmer still retained his membership in the church, and no charge had been
preferred against him except at Kirtland, when the High council broke up in confusion. He had been spoken against in
the meeting at Far West, on the 5th of February, by Elder George M. Hinkle, in these words: "David Whitmer's wrong in
persisting in the use of tea, coffee and tobacco," as will be seen by reference to the proceedings of that meeting as
published on page 118 of the August number of THE RETURN. On that occasion the three
Presidents (David and John Whitmer and Phelps), were voted against, which proceeding, evidently, was illegal. Of its
legality, however, we may speak more fully hereafter.
John Whitmer had been appointed by revelation to write and keep a regular history, and record of the church, as will be
seen by the following:
"Revelation to Joseph Smith, jr., and John Whitmer, given March, 1831.
1. Behold it is expedient in me
[133]
that my servant John should write and keep a regular history, and assist you, my servant Joseph, in transcribing all
things which shall be given you, until he is called to further duties. Again, verily I say unto you, that he can also
lift up his voice in meetings, whenever it shall be expedient.
2. And again, I say unto you, that it shall be appointed unto him to keep the church record and history continually,
for Oliver Cowdery I have appointed to another office. Wherefore it shall be given him, inasmuch as he is faithful,
by the Comforter, to write these things. Even so. Amen."
In conformity with the above command and appointment, he had kept the church history and record, but now it was desirable
to have possession of them but he refused to give them up whereupon the following remarkable letter was sent to him,
which we copy from the history of Joseph Smith, jr., as found on page 133 of the "Mil. Star," in which the writers seemed
to consider their judgment superior to that expressed in the foregoing revelation.
"Mr. J. Whitmer: Sir: We were desirous of honoring you by giving publicity to your notes on the history of the church of
Latter Day Saints after making such corrections as we thought would be necessary, knowing your incompetency as a
historian, that writings coming from your pen, could not be put to press without correcting them, or else the church must
suffer reproach. Indeed, sir, we never supposed you capable of writing a history, but were willing to let it come out
under your name, notwithstanding it would really not be yours but ours. We are still willing to honor you, if you can be
made to know your own interest, and give up your notes, so that they can be corrected and made fit for the press; but if
not, we have all the materials for another, which we shall commence this week to write.
Your obedient servants,
JOSEPH SMITH, jr.
SIDNEY RIGDON,}
Presid'ts of the whole ch'rch of Lat'r-day S'nts
Attest, E. ROBINSON, Clerk.
No attention was paid to the foregoing letter by John Whitmer, as, perhaps, he thought he would not be justified in
thus surrendering the work which had been assigned him by revelation. The record was subsequently obtained, however,
and brought to our house, where we copied the entire record into another book, assisted a part of the time, by Dr.
Levi Richards.
On the 11th of April charges were preferred against Oliver Cowdery, and his trial came off on the 12th; and on the 13th
charges were preferred against David Whitmer and Lyman (E.) Johnson, and their trial was had the same day, as will be
seen by the following quotation from page 133, 16th vol. "Mil. Star."
"April 13th, the following charges were preferred against David Whitmer, before the High Council at Far West, in Council
assembled:
1st. For not observing the word of wisdom.
2nd. For unchristian-like conduct in neglecting to attend meetings, in uniting with and possessing the same spirit as
the dissenters.
3rd. In writing letters to the dissenters in Kirtland, unfavorable to the cause, and to the character of Joseph Smith,
junior.
4th. In neglecting the duties of his calling, and separating himself from the church while he had a name among us.
5th. For signing himself President of the church of Christ, after he had been cut off from the Presidency, in an
insulting letter to the High Council.
After reading the above charges, together with a letter sent to the president of said Council (a copy of which may be
found in Far West Record, Book A,) the Council considered the charges sustained, and consequently considered him
(David Whitmer) no longer a member of the church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
[134]
The same day three charges were preferred against Lyman E. Johnson, which were read, together with a letter from him,
in answer to the one recorded in Far West Record, Book A. The charges were sustained and he was cut off from the church."
The above is the only trial ever had in David Whitmer's case. The character of the charges speak for themselves.
If a failure to keep the word of wisdom was a test of fellowship at the present day, how many members in all churches
of the Latter Day Saints can be found, who use neither tea, coffee or tobacco? But notice, the Council do not say
they either expel or cut David Whitmer off, but, "the Council considered the charges sustained, and consequently
considered him (David Whitmer) no longer a member of the church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints." There is no
account that we can find, of the Church ever lifting their hands against him, which is required to be done by the law.
That these trials and proceedings were illegal, and without spiritual force or virtue, is evident from the manner they
were conducted.
In the first place, there is no record of their being labored with as the law of Christ demands, which says:
"Moreover, if thy brother shall trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone; if he
shall hear thee, thou hast gained thy brother.
But if he will not hear thee, then take with thee one or two more, that in the mouth of two or three witnesses
every word may be established.
And if he shall neglect to hear them, tell it unto the church; but if he neglect to hear the church, let him
be unto thee as an heathen man and a publican. -- Mat. 18:15, 16, 17.
That the above is the law for the church, we quote from the book of Doctrine and Covenants.
"Thou shalt take the things which thou hast received, which have been given unto thee in my scriptures for a law,
to be my law, to govern my church; and he that doeth according to these things, shall be saved, and he that doeth them
not shall be damned, if he continues." -- D. & C. 42:16.
The only mention made of any attempt to labor with these men, was made in the meeting on the 5th of February, more than
two months before their trial.
The practice of appointing a committee to go and visit several men as a body, does not comply with the commandment of
our Savior, as we understand it. Neither can a trial be considered legal where the court are prejudiced, and have
expressed an opinion, as had the Presidents and Counsellors done in the case of these men. See the statements made by
them in the meeting of February 5, as found on the 118th page of the Aug. Number of THE RETURN.
Therefore any action taken against David Whitmer, or others, dictated by such an influence and spirit, could not, in the
least, affect their spiritual standing before the Lord.
Thus we are fully convinced, from a careful examination of the records, and our personal knowledge of the proceedings,
that David Whitmer never was legally expelled from the Church.
Had these prosecutions of David Whitmer and others satisfied the authorities and members of the church, we would not be
called upon to record other scenes enacted, and outrages inflicted upon them, which would disgrace a barbarous people,
to say nothing of would be saints; but we leave the unpleasant recital until we reach it in the regular course of events.
In the meantime, that our readers may have as correct an idea of the situation of affairs in the church as possible, we
make further quotations from the history of Joseph Smith, jr., giving some of the revelations which he received those
days, as found on page 147, 16th vol. "Mil. Star," wherein he says:
"I received the following --
Revelation, given at Far West, April 17, 1838.
Verily thus saith the Lord, it is wisdom in my servant David W. Patten, that he settle up all his business as soon as
he possibly can, and make a disposition of his merchandise, that he may perform a mission
[135]
unto me next spring, in company with others, even twelve including himself, to testify of my name, and bear glad tidings
unto all the world; for verily thus saith the Lord, that inasmuch as there are those among you who deny my name, others
shall be planted in their stead and receive their Bishoprick. Amen."
Also I received the following --
Revelation given to Brigham Young at Far West, April 17, 1838.
Verily thus saith the Lord, let my servant Brigham Young go unto the place which he has bought, on Mill Creek, and
there provide for his family, until an effectual door is opened for his family, until I shall command him to go hence,
and not to leave his family until they are amply provided for. Amen.
I received the following --
Revelation given at Far West, April 16, 1838, making known the will of God concerning the building up of this place,
and of the Lord's House, &c.
Verily thus saith the Lord unto you, my servant Joseph Smith, junior, and also my servant Sidney Rigdon, and also my
servant Hyrum Smith, and your Counsellors who are and shall be appointed hereafter; and also unto you, my servant Edward
Partridge, and his Counsellors; and also unto my faithful servants who are of the High Council of my Church in Zion, (for
thus it shall be called), and unto all the Elders and people of my Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints scattered
abroad in all the world; for thus shall my church be called in the last days, even The Church of Jesus Christ of
Latter-day Saints. Verily I say unto you all: aArise and shine forth, that thy light may be a standard for the nations,
and that the gathering together upon the land of Zion, and upon her Stakes, may be for a defence, and for a refuge from
the storm, and from wrath when it shall be poured out without mixture upon the whole earth.
Let the city Far West, be a holy and consecrated land unto me, and it shall be called most holy, for the ground upon
which thou standest is holy; therefore, I command you to build a house unto me, for the gathering together of my Saints,
that they may worship me; and let there be a beginning of this work, and a foundation, and a preparatory work, this
following summer; and let the beginning be made on the 4th day of July next; and from that time forth let my people labor
diligently to build a house unto my name; and in aone year from this day let them re-commence laying the foundation of
my house; thus let them from that time forth labor diligently until it shall be finished, from the corner stone thereof
unto the top thereof, until there shall not anything remain that is not finished.
Verily I say unto you, let not my servant Joseph, neither my servant Sidney, neither my servant Hyrum, get in debt
any more for the building of a house unto my name; but let an house be built unto my name according to the apattern
which I will show unto them. And if my people build it not according to the pattern which I shall show unto their
Presidency, I will not accept it at their hands; but if my people do build it according to the pattern which I shall
shew unto their Presidency, even my servant Joseph and his Counsellors, then I will accept it at the hands of my
people. And again, verily I say unto you, it is my will that the city of Far West should be built up speedily by the
gathering of my Saints, and also that other places should be appointed for Stakes in the regions round about, as they
shall be manifested unto my servant Joseph, from time to time; for behold, I will be with him, and I will sanctify
him before the people, for unto him have I given the keys of this kingdom and ministry. Even so. Amen."
The next day, after receiving the above temple revelation, Joseph Smith, jr.,
[136]
commenced writing the church history, and continued to write from time to time, besides attending to other duties, as
will be seen by the following extracts from his history. -- "Mil. Star," pages 148-51.
"April 27th. This day I chiefly spent in writing a history of this church from the earliest period of its existence,
up to this date. * * *
Monday 30th, The First Presidency were engaged in writing the church history, and in recitation of grammar lessons,
which recitations at this period were usually attended each morning before writing.
May 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th, a838. The First Presidency were engaged in writing church history and administering to
the sick. Received a letter from John E. Page on the 4th. * * *
Sunday, May 6th. I preached to the saints, setting forth the evils that existed, and that would exist, by reason of
hasty judgment or decisions upon any subject given by any people, or in judging before they had heard both sides of a
question. I also cautioned the saints against men who came amongst them whining and growling about their money, because
they had kept the saints, and borne some of the burden with others, and thus thinking that others, who are still poorer,
and have borne greater burdens than they themselves, ought to make up their loss, &c. I cautioned the saints to beware
of such, for they were throwing out insinuations here and there, to level as it were a dart at the best interests of the
Church, and if possible destroy the character of its Presidency. I also gave some instructions in the mysteries of the
kingdom of God; such as the history of the planets, &c.; of Abraham's writings upon the planetary systems, &c. * * *
Saturday, May 12, 1838, President Rigdon and myself attended the High Council for the purpose of presenting for their
consideration some business relating to our pecuniary concerns.
We stated to the Council our situation, as to maintaining our families, and the relation we now stand in to the Church,
spending as we have for eight years, our time, talents, and property, in the service of the Church: and being reduced as
it were to beggary, and being still retained in the business and service of the Church, it appears necessary that
something should be done for the support of our families by the Church, or else we must do it by our own labors; and if
the Church say to us, "help yourselves," we will thank them and immediately do so; but if the Church say, "Serve us,"
some provision must be made for our sustenance.
The Council investigated the matter, and instructed the Bishop to make over to President Joseph Smith, junior, and
Sidney Rigdon, each an eighty-acre lot of land from the property of the Church, situated adjacent to the city corporation;
also appointed three of their number, viz., George W. Harris, Elias Higbee and Simeon Carter, a committee to confer with
said Presidency, and satisfy them for their services the present year; not for preaching, or for receiving the word of
God by revelation, neither for instructing the Saints in righteousness, but for services rendered in the printing
establishment, in translating the ancient records, &c., &c. Said committee agreed that Presidents Smith and Rigdon should
receive [$1,100 each] as a just remuneration for their services this year. * * *
The above named committee reported to the High Council, at a subsequent meeting, but the sum agreed upon is left blank in
the history, as printed. The amount they asked for was ELEVEN HUNDRED DOLLARS
each per annum.
The question was warmly discussed by the members of the Council until near sundown. George M. Hinkle bitterly opposed it,
as the church had always been opposed to a salaried ministry. A majority of the Council however, favored the measure,
so that when the vote
[137]
was called, eleven voted for it, and one against it. But when it was noised abroad that the Council had taken such a
step, the members of the church, almost to a man, lifted their voices against it. The expression of disapprobation was
so strong and emphatic, that at the next meeting of the High Council the resolution voting them a salary, was rescinded.
We were present, and acted as clerk of the Council at both meetings, therefore know whereof we affirm.
A few days after the High Council refused to give a salary to Joseph Smith, jr. and Sidney Rigdon, the TITHING revelation
of July 8, 1838, was given, in which the poor are not mentioned. But more on this subject hereafter. We now give further
quotations from the history of Joseph Smith, jr. in which he says:
"Friday, 18. I left Far West, in company with Sidney Rigdon, T. B. Marsh, D. W. Patten, Bishop Partridge, E. Higbee, S.
Carter, Alanson Ripley, and many others, for the purpose of visiting the North Country, and laying off a Stake of Zion;
making locations, and laying claim to lands to facilitate the gathering of the Saints, and for the benefit of the poor,
in upholding the Church of God. We travelled to the mouth of Honey creek, which is a tributary of Grand River, where we
camped for the night. * * *
Saturday, 19. This morning we struck our tents, and formed a line of march, crossing Grand River at the mouth of Honey
Creek and Nelson's Ferry. Grand River is a large, beautiful, deep and rapid stream, during the high waters of spring,
and will undoubtedly admit of steam boat navigation, and other water craft; and at the mouth of Honey Creek are a
splendid harbor and a good landing.
We pursued our course up the river, mostly through timber, for about eighteen miles, when we arrived at Colonel Lyman
Wight's who [lives] at the foot of Tower Hill (a name I gave the place in consequence of the remains of an old Nephite
altar or tower that stood there), where we camped for the Sabbath.
In the afternoon I went up the river about half a mile to Wight's Ferry, accompanied by President Rigdon, and clerk,
George W. Robinson, for the purpose of selecting and laying claim to a city plat near said ferry in Daviess County,
township 60, range 27 and 28, and sections 25, 36, 31, and 30, which the brethren called Spring Hill, but by the mouth
of the Lord it was named ADAM-ONDI-AHAM [sic], because, said He, it is the place where Adam shall come
to visit his people, or the Ancient of days shall sit, as spoken of by Daniel the Prophet." -- Mil. Star, page 152
16th vol.
To be Continued.
|